Read America Constitution A Biography Akhil Reed Amar 8601405725349 Books
Read America Constitution A Biography Akhil Reed Amar 8601405725349 Books
Download As PDF : America Constitution A Biography Akhil Reed Amar 8601405725349 Books
In America’s Constitution, one of this era’s most accomplished constitutional law scholars, Akhil Reed Amar, gives the first comprehensive account of one of the world’s great political texts. Incisive, entertaining, and occasionally controversial, this “biography” of America’s framing document explains not only what the Constitution says but also why the Constitution says it.
We all know this much the Constitution is neither immutable nor perfect. Amar shows us how the story of this one relatively compact document reflects the story of America more generally. (For example, much of the Constitution, including the glorious-sounding “We the People,” was lifted from existing American legal texts, including early state constitutions.) In short, the Constitution was as much a product of its environment as it was a product of its individual creators’ inspired genius.
Despite the Constitution’s flaws, its role in guiding our republic has been nothing short of amazing. Skillfully placing the document in the context of late-eighteenth-century American politics, America’s Constitution explains, for instance, whether there is anything in the Constitution that is unamendable; the reason America adopted an electoral college; why a president must be at least thirty-five years old; and why–for now, at least–only those citizens who were born under the American flag can become president.
From his unique perspective, Amar also gives us unconventional wisdom about the Constitution and its significance throughout the nation’s history. For one thing, we see that the Constitution has been far more democratic than is conventionally understood. Even though the document was drafted by white landholders, a remarkably large number of citizens (by the standards of 1787) were allowed to vote up or down on it, and the document’s later amendments eventually extended the vote to virtually all Americans.
We also learn that the Founders’ Constitution was far more slavocratic than many would acknowledge the “three fifths” clause gave the South extra political clout for every slave it owned or acquired. As a result, slaveholding Virginians held the presidency all but four of the Republic’s first thirty-six years, and proslavery forces eventually came to dominate much of the federal government prior to Lincoln’s election.
Ambitious, even-handed, eminently accessible, and often surprising, America’s Constitution is an indispensable work, bound to become a standard reference for any student of history and all citizens of the United States.
From the Hardcover edition.
Read America Constitution A Biography Akhil Reed Amar 8601405725349 Books
""America's Constitution..." is a serious, scholarly book, but so lucidly written that the lay reader will have no problem following the text or comprehending the theme. This book is a major work on the topic and so well done that 5-stars are easily earned. Other books of similar intent, such as Professor Jack Rakove's book Original Meanings: Politics and Ideas in the Making of the Constitution, may succeed in analysis, but frequently leave the lay reader with a hard slog for comprehension.
Professor Amar blends three perspectives in his look at the constitution: history, law and political science. And that three-viewed approach is what yeilds the depth of penetration that this book presents. The issue of the young nation's "peculiar institution" (slavery) for example, is shown to be infused well beyond what the casual reader might see in reading the constitution.
By illustrating the norms and mores of the late 18th century, citing the record of the constitution and ratification papers - both Federalist and Anti-Federalist, as well as analysis of court decisions that have followed - Professor Amar makes his case with clear documentation and solid logical argument for both the good and bad; and there is no mistaking that the "good" triumphs. He tells us what we need to know about our constitution, not what its detractors or its exalters insist on. Highly recommended if a very in-depth look at the U.S. Constitution, its original meanings and historic evolution are your interest.
-----kindle edition-----
It is always disappointing in a book such as this (one that can be used for reference) that hardcopy page numbers are not provided. References from kindle to hardcopy or the reverse are difficult to impossible. Digital media or not - page numbers are still (unfortunately) the only common denominator. And, if EVER a book needed an index - this is it. Re-finding passages of interest are now left entirely to highlighting which can become overwhelming in a 655 page book - especially one with as much to say as this one, yet NO index is provided. For expediency, the publisher has eliminated the index from the e-book version - but retains the same price as the paper copy! e-Book publication quality, ★★☆☆☆ for typically rapacious Random House."
Product details
|
Tags : America's Constitution A Biography [Akhil Reed Amar] on . In <b>America’s Constitution</b>, one of this era’s most accomplished constitutional law scholars,Akhil Reed Amar,America's Constitution A Biography,Random House,0812972724,Constitutions,Constitutional history - United States,Constitutional history;United States.,United States,CONSTITUTIONAL LAW,Constitution government the state,Constitutional history,GENERAL,General Adult,HISTORY / United States / General,History,History/United States - General,Juvenile Nonfiction / Language Arts / General,LAW / Constitutional,Non-Fiction,POLITICAL SCIENCE / Constitutions,Political Science,Politics / Current Events,Politics/International Relations,Politics/Intl Relations,U.S. CONSTITUTIONAL HISTORY,United States - General,constitution of the united states;biographies;biography;history;law;constitution;politics;nonfiction;American history;government;constitutional law;legal history;constitutional history;US history;US;U.S. Constitution;legal;USA;democracy;United States history;political science;American politics;history books;nonfiction books;historical non fiction;culture;cultural history;society;social history;non fiction;social studies;history book;historical;historical non fiction books;historic,history; law; constitution; politics; nonfiction; American history; government; constitutional law; legal history; constitutional history; US history; US; U.S. Constitution; legal; USA; democracy; United States history; political science; American politics; history books; nonfiction books; historical non fiction; culture; cultural history; society; social history; non fiction; social studies; history book; historical; historical non fiction books; historic; biographies; biography; constitution of the united states,HISTORY / United States / General,History/United States - General,Juvenile Nonfiction / Language Arts / General,LAW / Constitutional,POLITICAL SCIENCE / Constitutions,United States - General,Politics / Current Events,Constitutional Law,U.S. Constitutional History,Constitutional history,Political Science,Politics/International Relations,Constitution government the state
America Constitution A Biography Akhil Reed Amar 8601405725349 Books Reviews :
America Constitution A Biography Akhil Reed Amar 8601405725349 Books Reviews
- "America's Constitution..." is a serious, scholarly book, but so lucidly written that the lay reader will have no problem following the text or comprehending the theme. This book is a major work on the topic and so well done that 5-stars are easily earned. Other books of similar intent, such as Professor Jack Rakove's book Original Meanings Politics and Ideas in the Making of the Constitution, may succeed in analysis, but frequently leave the lay reader with a hard slog for comprehension.
Professor Amar blends three perspectives in his look at the constitution history, law and political science. And that three-viewed approach is what yeilds the depth of penetration that this book presents. The issue of the young nation's "peculiar institution" (slavery) for example, is shown to be infused well beyond what the casual reader might see in reading the constitution.
By illustrating the norms and mores of the late 18th century, citing the record of the constitution and ratification papers - both Federalist and Anti-Federalist, as well as analysis of court decisions that have followed - Professor Amar makes his case with clear documentation and solid logical argument for both the good and bad; and there is no mistaking that the "good" triumphs. He tells us what we need to know about our constitution, not what its detractors or its exalters insist on. Highly recommended if a very in-depth look at the U.S. Constitution, its original meanings and historic evolution are your interest.
-----kindle edition-----
It is always disappointing in a book such as this (one that can be used for reference) that hardcopy page numbers are not provided. References from kindle to hardcopy or the reverse are difficult to impossible. Digital media or not - page numbers are still (unfortunately) the only common denominator. And, if EVER a book needed an index - this is it. Re-finding passages of interest are now left entirely to highlighting which can become overwhelming in a 655 page book - especially one with as much to say as this one, yet NO index is provided. For expediency, the publisher has eliminated the index from the e-book version - but retains the same price as the paper copy! e-Book publication quality, ★★☆☆☆ for typically rapacious Random House. - The U.S. Constitution is a huge subject, and Prof. Amar contributes in this book by keeping a focus on the ideas and debates that led up to or were contemporary with adoption of each of the Constitution's clauses. It touches on virtually every phrase.
A reader might come to the book looking for other things that Prof. Amar does not try to provide in particular, lessons from his analysis of then-contemporary debates that might be useful for now-contemporary debates.
For example, on Presidential impeachment, Prof. Amar discusses the phrase "Treason, Bribery, and other high Crimes and Misdemeanors," noting that "high" was not used in the Constitution to describe the standard for impeachment of other officials, and noting that treason and bribery set the standard for what is referred to by the general terms "crimes and misdemeanors," etc. He closes by using Andrew Johnson's acquittal to illustrate. Period, end of story. I mean, what else could a reader from today's generation want to hear about, regarding standards for Presidential impeachment? (Good grief.)
In my case, I was interested in what the Founders thought about "enumeration," both in the sense of "census" (which the book does not touch on) and in the sense of enumerated and unenumerated rights. On the latter, Prof. Amar is clear "While this book has focused on the written and enacted Constitution, I myself do not believe that all of American constitutionalism can be deduced simply from the document. At key points the text itself seems to gesture outward, reminding readers of the importance of unenumerated rights above and beyond textually enumerated ones. Thus we need at least one more book to start where this one ends." And yet this book does touch on the subject, assertively if lightly, in its discussion of "No State shall" under the fourteenth amendment, where the author states that the Supreme Court construes the Constitution as providing a right of privacy. The author also refers us to his previous book on the Bill of Rights.
In addition, I was interested in seeing what I could learn about the liberty-empire range of perspectives concerning U.S. colonial history.
First, I have to report that the indigenous peoples do not make much of an appearance in the book, the word "indigenous" not at all. While this may accurately reflect the level of interest in indigenous peoples in the Constitution's text and debates, it contrasts mightily with the book's substantial focus on African-Americans, who Prof. Amar notes are mentioned in the Constitution's text not at all.
In general, however, Prof. Amar is non-judgmental on empire. The "Territory" section of Chapter 7 on "States and Territories" notes the colonies' "struggle to wrest the [trans-Appalachian] West from England" as part of the independence movement. With respect to the subsequent Constitution, the book notes that "the union was broke," that Federalist Paper No. 38 characterized the West as "a mine of vast wealth," and that "the first wave of income would flow from land sales."
However, Prof. Amar's book doesn't mention that Britain also was broke from the expenses of winning France's withdrawal, or the role of the hated taxes in repairing that. The book's frequent references to George Washington's influence on the country's direction do not include mention of his role in conquering western land for commercial sale. The book does however slightly puncture the "no taxation without representation" rationale where it says, "Not that the colonists really wanted direct representation in Parliament. A small number of Americans amid a sea of British legislators would likely be consistently outvoted."
Contrasted with the book's adopting as a major theme the expansion of liberty accomplished through the Constitution and its amendments, the near non-treatment of empire places the book towards the right in the political spectrum in that particular regard.
While this gap regarding "empire" reflects an interest of my own, in a finite book gaps must necessarily be infinite, so I should close by saying that what is there in the book is substantial and worthwhile. - Wow. That's all I can say about this tremendous treatment of the Constitution and its history. Akhil Amar has written the definitive textual analysis of the Constitution. His arguments are clear and incisive, and his copious notes, both within the text itself and in end notes at the rear of the book, provide a wealth of excellent source material for further research. Professor Amar brilliantly showcases the strengths and weaknesses of the document, and brings to life the energetic debates surrounding its ratification and amendments.
Readers should be warned though -- this is not a book for beginners. The author presumes (and given what he is trying to do here, rightly so) that the reader has pursued some study of both American history and the U.S. Constitution. Readers should have a decent familiarity with both before reading this. That being said, if you are looking for a deep, rich look at the history and meaning of the Constitution, this book is a must buy.
Comments
Post a Comment